Among the organs of people's power that emerged after Great October in the process of creating a new, Soviet state apparatus, the Petrograd Revolutionary Tribunal was formed on December 3, 1917. The old courts, which were "primarily an apparatus of oppression, an apparatus of bourgeois exploitation" 1 were scrapped by the working people. Instead, the workers began to "organize their own, workers 'and peasants', courts"2 . They were called differently: the court of public conscience, the revolutionary tribunal, and so on. They included representatives from party organizations (the Bolsheviks, and at first also the Left SRS), from the Soviets, from the factory committees. Their activities were based on the will of the revolutionary people. 3
An important role in the formation of new judicial bodies was played by "Decree on the court No. 1", adopted by the Council of People's Commissars on November 22, 1917. He proclaimed democratic and direct elections of people's judges and assessors, established the principle of their turnover and the nature of cases to be considered in local courts. The decree abolished the old prosecutor's office, which was particularly hated by the working people .4 According to the decree, revolutionary tribunals were formed to fight against encroachments on the socialist revolution and conquest
1 " V. I. Lenin. PSS. Vol. 36, p. 162.
2 Ibid., p. 197.
3 "Materials of the People's Commissariat of Justice". Issue II. Moscow, 1918, pp. 34-39.
4 N. V. Krylenko. Sud i pravo v SSSR [Court and Law in the USSR], Part 1, Moscow, 1927, p. 91.
page 211
workers, with looting and predation, with sabotage and various abuses. Cases were considered in the Tribunals by the presiding judge and six ordinary assessors. The instruction of the People's Commissariat of Justice, issued on December 19, 1917, clarified the working procedure of such tribunals .5
One of the very first cases considered in December 1917. The Petrograd Revolutionary Tribunal 6, was the case of S. V. Panina. This Countess is a hereditary aristocrat who came from the richest families of the Panins and Maltsevs (on her mother's side). Her estates were located in Marfina, near Moscow, in Valuyki, Voronezh Province, and in the Crimea. The richness of Panina's Crimean estate can be judged by the impression it made on Leo Tolstoy and his daughter, who were invited by the Countess to stay with her in 1901: "Lev Nikolaevich, who was used to the simple, modest, if not poor, environment of Yasnaya Polyana, looked at her house almost with fear"; those who lived in the village of Yasnaya Polyana were very happy. Alexandra Lvovna felt the same way: "I was struck by the luxury of the palace. I've never lived in a house like this. It was awkward and uncomfortable: marble windowsills, carved doors, heavy expensive furniture, large, high rooms. " 7 But Panina was known not only for her wealth. She was a prominent figure in the political arena, being a member of the Central Committee of the Cadet Party. V. I. Lenin considered her one of the most influential figures of this party .8 Since May 1917. Panina became a companion of the Minister of State Charity in the Provisional Government, and in August was appointed to the post of a companion of the Minister, but already in the Department of Public Education .9
The Countess was reputed to be a patron of the arts, a representative of liberal enlightenment. During the pre-revolutionary period, she built the People's House in St. Petersburg, where cultural, educational and mass agitation work was carried out, including by the Social Democrats. 10 The Countess created educational classes for children of the poor and illiterate adults, free libraries, established scholarships for poor students and, thanks to this, enjoyed popularity among the liberal intelligentsia. The bourgeois press celebrated her as the personification of "enlightenment, kindness, nobility and unselfishness." As D. I. Meissner, who met her, recalled, she "knew how to be personally attentive and responsive"11 . However , it is not necessary to exalt its "virtues" in any way12, because charity and educational activities did not prevent Panina from faithfully serving her class. The same Meissner recognized: "Panina, clearly aware of the importance of the national enlightenment for Russia, still always remained on the right flank of Russian liberalism. This was especially clearly defined in the months when not only the old Russian statehood, which many of Countess Panina's ancestors served in the first roles, but also the entire age-old way of social and political relations collapsed."13
Panina met the victory of the socialist revolution with hostility, immediately taking the path of sabotaging the people's power. She officially ordered to immediately and secretly withdraw 93 thousand rubles that were available in the cash register of the old ministry and not to transfer them to the administration of the People's Commissariat of Education. I. B. Rogalsky, a representative of the commissariat, came to the former ministry to receive cases and found that the cash register of the institution was empty. A criminal case was opened against Panina on the concealment of state funds, and on November 28, 1917. she was detained. When questioned by the investigative commission for combating counter-revolution, the Countess stated that she did not recognize the authority of the People's Commissars and would only give an account of her activities to the Constituent Assembly. On the map-
5 SU RSFSR, 1917, N 12.
6 See more about him: A.V. Krasnikova. We will build a new world. l. 1967, pp. 74-75.
7 I. A. Bunin. Collected Works, vol. 9, Moscow, 1967, pp. 102-103.
8 See V. I. Lenin. PSS. Vol. 34, p. 57.
9 "Russian wealth", 1917, N 11-12, p. 285.
10 In May 1906, at a rally in Panina's house, Lenin spoke under the name Karpov. At that time, he tore off the false mask of the Cadets as representatives of the" half-hearted, timid liberal bourgeoisie seeking a deal with the old government " (V. I. Lenin, PSS. Vol. 13, p.92).
11 D. Meissner. Mirages and reality. Notes of an Emigrant, Moscow, 1966, p. 170.
12 Unfortunately, this trend is sometimes felt even in some of the newest works of Soviet authors. So, in a substantial documentary story about the prominent Bolshevik P. A. Krasikov, in particular, it is indicated that Panina "even in her youth, having engaged in charity, gained fame as a woman of the front line, unselfishly loving the people" (V. Budanin. To whom to administer justice, Moscow, 1975, p. 400).
13 D. Meissner. Op. ed., p. 169.
page 212
Panina categorically refused repeated offers to return the people's money or indicate the location of its location. I had to refer her case to the Petrograd Revolutionary Tribunal.
At the time of the Countess's arrest, a meeting of representatives of the Central Committee of the Cadet Party was taking place in her apartment with the participation of members of the deposed Provisional Government, F. F. Kokoshkin and A. I. Shingarev. After the arrest of the "people's benefactress", the counter-revolutionaries launched a broad campaign. The bourgeois press declared the Countess a "victim" and an " ascetic." Panin's petitioners were pounding the doors of Soviet institutions demanding her release, and various lawyers and some of her former ministry colleagues were crammed into official defenders. Her chosen defense lawyer, acting by proxy, visited the Petrograd Revolutionary Tribunal, where he interviewed the heads of the Petrograd Soviet Investigative Commission, M. Y. Kozlovsky and P. A. Krasikov, got acquainted with the client's case, and received unhindered permission to meet with her .14 He shared his impressions of visiting the revtribunal with readers, not hiding his surprise. First of all, he was surprised by the fact that he was dealing not only with professional lawyers, but with ordinary workers and employees: "There were people in the tribunal hall. A young worker-the building manager, some of the judges, also workers, couriers transferred from the district court. " 15 The official file issued for review also seemed unusual to him. It was prepared by people who were not yet experienced. "When," continued the lawyer, " having read the case, I finally left the Palace of People's Justice, I carried away with me the impression of something neither particularly dangerous nor strong, poorly organized and highly Russian." And here is his description of the meeting with the defendant: "A date... it took place under conditions quite appropriate to the circumstances. The defense lawyer was given the opportunity to talk to her for a long time and without witnesses, not through the bars, but in the duty room ...the attitude towards her is impeccable, even attentive. " 16
It was December 11, the opening day of the first session of the Petrograd Revolutionary Tribunal. The hall, which was located in the former palace of Grand Duke Nicholas Nikolaevich on the Petrogradskaya side, was crowded. The trial was attended by representatives of various strata of the population, although the majority were counter-revolutionary elements: former court officials, idle philistines, relatives and acquaintances of the defendant, journalists of bourgeois newspapers that were not yet closed at that time. This audience behaved provocatively, sometimes provocatively. When the defendant was brought into the hall, the corresponding part of the audience demonstratively rose from their seats and gave Panina a standing ovation. "It is only fair to point out," her lawyer wrote on this occasion, " that the Bolshevik People's Court and the Bolshevik part of the audience present in the courtroom showed great restraint during this demonstration. They made no attempt to stifle her or upset her with hostile interventions. They waited patiently until it subsided of its own accord, and then the trial began. " 17 In the judges ' seats at the table were the chairman of the tribunal, I. P. Zhukov, a carpenter at the Erikson factory, and the assessors, as well as ordinary representatives of the working people, mostly workers specially assigned by the enterprises of Petrograd.
Opening the first meeting of the Revolutionary Tribunal, the chairman addressed the audience with a brief opening speech. He recalled that "revolutionary courts, which were called revolutionary tribunals, also emerged in France. And just as those first revolutionary courts, so the Russian revolutionary tribunal that has now begun to live, I hope will be a strict appraiser, the most ardent defender of the rights and customs of the Russian revolution. He will strictly judge all those who go against the will of the people, who will hinder him on the way. And I am sure that those who are innocent before the will of the revolutionary people will find in the revolutionary tribunal the most reliable defender."18 Having solemnly declared the hearing open, Zhukov then turned to the defendant with the question: does she recognize
14 N. Zubov. The first Chairman of the Small Council of People's Commissars, Moscow, 1975, p. 135.
15 "Russian wealth", 1917, N 11-12, p. 288.
16 Ibid., p. 289.
17 Ibid., p. 290.
18 "Izvestiya VTSIK", 12. XII. 1917.
page 213
plead guilty? After her negative answer, he invited the clerk of the court to read out the report of the investigative commission, which set out the essence of the case, and then appealed to everyone in the courtroom to speak.
The defendant's defense lawyer was the first to take the floor, although this was a violation of "old procedural traditions". He began to praise the personal qualities and charity work of the defendant, justifying her actions in every possible way, and tried to discredit the process. "Now there is no law that is recognized by everyone," he said, " and your decrees are not recognized by everyone." Then he accused the new court of party-political bias and, referring to the patronage of Panina, said that it is impossible to judge her "according to conscience"; " so, it remains to judge her in the party. Then there is no need to cover it with all the attributes of lawsuits. Then it's a civil war. " 19
The audience was seething and bubbling. A certain Ivanov, who called himself a "worker", demanded the floor. He spoke unsteadily, and it was obvious that his speech had been prepared beforehand. Praising Panina's" highly humane and useful to the people " activities, he said that the defendant had helped him, a hitherto dark man, learn to "love science and life", and, turning to the Countess, exclaimed: "Thank you!"20 . The anti-Soviet audience gave him a standing ovation. Bourgeois newspapers later wrote in their reports on the trial: "The worker Ivanov made a warm, sincere, simple, easy speech." 21 Then Naumov, a worker at the Novy Parviainen plant, came out of the audience and acted as an accuser. He approved the actions of the new court, which brought Panina to justice as a saboteur. "The oppressed class has gained power by blood and cannot and should not suffer the insults of this power," he said, and then showed that the Countess's case is not of a private nature and is of fundamental importance. "Now we have before us not a single individual," Naumov said, " but an active party and class activist. She, along with all the representatives of her class, participated in organized opposition to the people's power, and this is her crime, for which she is subject to trial." Naumov stressed that sabotage is a crime against workers who have started building a new life. Arguing with the lawyer, he said:: "I am ready to agree that in the past, Citizen Panina brought benefits to the people... But that is what distinguishes their nobility, to give or throw pieces to the people when they are enslaved, and to hinder them in their struggle when they want to be free. Let the populist Countess Panina really be kind and noble. But now the people have come to power... Here, even generosity did not help, and what could only be hindered... Let the tribunal remember that we have the right to be free, and anyone who does not want to understand this is subject to neutralization. Citizen Panina interfered with the people in their work. Act, citizen judges, not for one-sided generosity, but for the benefit of millions. " 22
It is characteristic that the bourgeois newspapers, which presented Ivanov's speech almost verbatim, actually silenced the speech of the worker Naumov. It was reproduced only by the Bolshevik press. In the course of a further trial, the accusation was fully proved. It turned out that the stolen funds were supposed to be used to finance saboteurs and other anti-Soviet purposes. The lack of these funds in the cash register led to the termination of remuneration for education workers and caused additional difficulties in the activities of the People's Commissariat of Education. After hearing the last word of the defendant, the tribunal left for a meeting, after which Zhukov announced the verdict. The Petrograd Revolutionary Tribunal decided: "Leave citizen Sofya Vladimirovna Panina in custody until the return of the people's money taken by her to the cash register of the Commissariat for Public Education. The Revolutionary Tribunal considers citizen Sofya Vladimirovna Panina guilty of opposing the people's power, but, taking into account the past of the accused, it is limited to bringing Citizen Panina to public censure. " 23 A few days later, the hidden money was handed over to the Soviet authorities, after which the Countess was released. She continued to conduct active counter-revolutionary activities, and later became a White immigrant.
19 E. N. Gorodetsky. The birth of the Soviet State, Moscow, 1965, p. 343.
20 "Izvestiya VTSIK", 12. XII. 1917.
21 N. Zubov. Op. ed., p. 135.
22 A. B. Krasnikova. Op. ed., pp. 76-77.
23 "Izvestiya VTSIK", 12. XII. 1917.
page 214
Pointing out such cases, Lenin wrote:: "If we are guilty of anything, it is that we were too humane, too kind-hearted towards the monstrous representatives of the bourgeois-imperialist system, who were treacherous in their treachery."24 . In the future, the experience of the bitter civil war, the intensified class struggle, and the vicious crimes committed by the enemies of the working people gradually taught the working people to better protect their power and interests. As for the new judicial instances, the Regulation on the People's Court of the RSFSR of November 30, 1918,25 strengthened them organizationally, and the consolidation of revolutionary legality on the basis of democratic centralism became an important factor in the progress of the national legal order.
24 V. I. Lenin. PSS. Vol. 35, p. 283.
25 SU RSFSR, 1918, N 85.
page 215
Новые публикации: |
Популярные у читателей: |
Новинки из других стран: |
![]() |
Контакты редакции |
О проекте · Новости · Реклама |
|
Либмонстр Россия ® Все права защищены.
2014-2026, LIBMONSTER.RU - составная часть международной библиотечной сети Либмонстр (открыть карту) Сохраняя наследие России |
Россия
Беларусь
Украина
Казахстан
Молдова
Таджикистан
Эстония
Россия-2
Беларусь-2
США-Великобритания
Швеция
Сербия