R. ANDREESHEV, Candidate of Economic Sciences
HOPES AND CONCERNS OF THE ORGANIZATION'S MEMBER COUNTRIES
The abbreviation SCO is increasingly used in the media when it comes to solving political and economic problems related to Asian states in one way or another. And although it is known that the SCO, or Shanghai Cooperation Organization , is a political association of only 6 countries, the influence of this "six" now goes far beyond the borders of the states that are its direct participants. For 7 years of its existence in its current form, the SCO has turned into a virtually new "center of power", which cannot be ignored not only by political" players " in the Asian space, but also by European powers, the United States, influential states of the Middle East, and other countries of the world. What is the modern Shanghai Cooperation Organization? What is the basis of its authority and political influence? What problems do the SCO member states face? What are the prospects for this organization? The answer to these and other similar questions can be found in the article published today.
The Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) is a sub - regional international organization that includes six states - China, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Russia, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. The total territory of the SCO member states is 61% of the territory of Eurasia. Its combined demographic potential is one-fourth of the world's population, and its economic potential includes the most powerful Chinese economy after the United States1.
The formation of the SCO was initiated by the signing by Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, China, Russia and Tajikistan in April 1996 in Shanghai of the "Agreement on Confidence-building measures in the military field in the area of the joint Border". Initially, the organization was called the "Shanghai Five", which follows from the above list of member states of the organization - at first there were five of them. At that time, the main factor uniting them was the civil war in Afghanistan between the troops of the Northern Alliance and the Taliban, which posed a threat to the security of the territories of all five states. They also took into account the common task of combating such challenges and threats as international terrorism, separatism and extremism, drug trafficking, etc. 2
In 1996-2000, the leaders of these countries met alternately in Shanghai, Moscow, Almaty, Bishkek, and Dushanbe. Constant joint work has gradually expanded the range of interests of the five member countries to the areas of foreign policy, economy, environmental protection, culture, etc. 3
FROM THE TOP FIVE TO THE TOP SIX
On June 14-15, 2001, a meeting of the heads of six states-Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, China, Russia, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan, which joined them, was held in Shanghai, where the SCO was announced. The Declaration on the Establishment of the SCO adopted at this summit proclaimed as its main goals: promotion of effective cooperation in political, trade, economic, scientific and technical, cultural, educational, energy, transport, environmental and other fields, as well as joint efforts to maintain and ensure peace, security and stability in the region.4
The Convention on Combating Terrorism, Separatism and Extremism was another important document signed during the summit. It defined separatism and extremism as violent and criminally persecutable5. Most of all, the signing of this document was in the interests of two countries-China and Uzbekistan. At that time, China was concerned about the separatist actions of Uighurs living in the western part of the country near the borders with Central Asia (CA). And Uzbekistan (the largest Central Asian state by population) was afraid of manifestations of separatism on the part of radical supporters of the restoration of an Islamic caliphate in the region.
At the second meeting of the Heads of State of the SCO member States, held in June 2002 in St. Petersburg, the SCO Charter, the Agreement between the member States on the Regional Anti - Terrorist Structure (RATS) and the Declaration of the Heads of State of this organization were signed.
The Charter has become a basic statutory document that sets out the directions of cooperation of countries proclaimed in the Declaration, sets out the goals and principles of the organization, gives the "six" an international status and defines its internal structure, as well as the mechanism for shaping the political course of states and building their relations with other countries and organizations.6
The Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure was created to improve cooperation between the six member states in the fight against terrorism, separatism, extremism, illegal drug and arms trafficking, as well as illegal migration, and has the status of a permanent SCO body. Its functions include coordinating the actions of law enforcement agencies
page 10
bodies and special services of the organization's member States 7.
In May 2003, at the next summit in Moscow, documents were signed regulating the work of the SCO bodies, determining the procedure for forming and executing the budget, as well as other issues related to the current work of various divisions of the organization. Its emblem and flag 8 were adopted.
In terms of population and the overall size of its territory, the SCO has no equal in the world. The strategic partnership between the two nuclear Powers and the permanent members of the UN Security Council-the Russian Federation and the People's Republic of China - underlines the importance of the organization. Naturally, such a partnership cannot but have an impact on building a collective security system in Central Asia and the Asia-Pacific region.
Cooperation in the field of anti - terrorism is one of the system-forming elements of the SCO. However, it would be wrong to consider this association a purely military organization. First, because its member countries are already members of various international organizations and are bound by various obligations, including non-participation in military blocs and alliances. Secondly, because the SCO member - China-generally traditionally adheres to the line of non-alignment with the blocs of any states.9
ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE
To fulfill the goals and objectives of the SCO Charter, the following bodies were established within the organization::
- Council of Heads of State (CSG);
- Council of Heads of Government;
- Council of Foreign Ministers (CFM);
- Meetings of heads of ministries and departments;
- Council of National Coordinators (ENC);
- Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure (RATS) - a permanent body;
- The Secretariat is a permanent administrative body 10.
The functions and working procedures of the SCO bodies are determined by the relevant regulations.
The SGG, the highest body of the SCO, determines the priorities and develops the main directions of the organization's activities, resolves fundamental issues of its internal structure and functioning, interaction with other states and international organizations, and also considers the most pressing international problems. The Council may also take a decision on the establishment of other SCO bodies, which is formalized in the form of additional protocols to the Charter.
The SRS accepts the organization's budget, which is formed on the basis of the principle of shared participation, considers and resolves issues related to specific, especially economic, areas of interaction development within the organization.
Decisions in the SCO bodies are made by consensus.
The working procedure of all the bodies of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization was finalized and adopted at the Moscow summit in 2003. The main structures of the organization started working in January 2004,11 after which, as can be assumed, this association functions as a full-fledged international organization.
In 2003, the first SCO budget was adopted in the amount of $ 3.8 million, which was mainly spent on the deployment of various units of the organization.12
At a meeting in Beijing in June 2006, the leaders of the SCO member States noted the successful completion of the organization's organizational and legal development, which creates conditions for its effective performance of its functions.13
THE EXTENSION IS POSSIBLE BUT... no need. while
The role, authority and importance of the SCO are gradually growing, and other countries, and not only Asian ones, are showing interest in it. Naturally, from time to time there is a question of membership in this association.
Currently, India, Iran, Pakistan and Mongolia have been granted observer status with the organization. Belarus and Sri Lanka are also seeking this status. And the United States has already received a refusal on its application to join the SCO.
Officially, the organization declares that it is interested in intensifying cooperation with observer States. However, none of the applicants ' applications for membership have been met, although it positions itself as an open association. In this context, an increase in the SCO membership is unlikely to be expected in the near future14.
The participating countries agree that it is necessary to postpone the expansion of the organization for the time being, while referring to the need to work out in detail the procedure for accepting new members.
There is an explanation for this position. First, the SCO members are afraid of attempts to "dilute" the organization and, as a result, reduce its "weight" in the world community. Secondly, the entry of India and Pakistan into the SCO can reduce the effectiveness of its work, since the foreign policy interests of these countries differ significantly. Third,
page 11
The final development of a mechanism for admitting new members to the SCO and its use will put the organization in a delicate position in connection with Iran's request to join it. On the one hand, sooner or later we will have to consider this appeal and make some gestures towards Iran. On the other hand, against the background of the aggravation of the situation around the Iranian nuclear program, the admission of this country to a regional association could give it a block character, which was not envisaged from the very beginning. SCO members and observers do not want to engage in direct confrontation with either the Americans or the Europeans. For example, they cannot ignore the fact that India has very good relations with the US and the EU. And China's economic interest in cooperation with the United States is so great that the Chinese leadership is unlikely to allow anything to complicate bilateral economic relations with this country.
MULTI-COLOR COOPERATION SPECTRUM
The Shanghai Cooperation Organization is a multi-disciplinary cooperation mechanism. It has established procedures for regular meetings of secretaries of the security councils of the SCO member states, general prosecutors, ministers responsible for foreign economic activity, defense, transport, culture and environmental protection, heads of rescue services and border agencies, and chairmen of supreme courts. Joint counterterrorism exercises are being conducted. Agreements were signed on cooperation in combating illicit trafficking in narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, on cooperation in providing assistance in emergency situations, on interbank contacts, etc. Customs and environmental services, specialists in the field of education, technical regulations and standards joined the cooperation.
There is a "Bishkek Group" of heads of law enforcement agencies and special services of the SCO member states. The group has developed an interstate program of joint measures to combat terrorism, separatism, extremism and other dangerous types of crimes.
Coordination of the organization's member States ' foreign policy activities has been established. Joint action programs are developed annually on the basis of the Protocol on Cooperation and Coordination between the Ministries of Foreign Affairs of the Association's member countries. Memoranda of understanding were signed between the SCO and CIS secretariats, as well as between the SCO and ASEAN. The SCO - Afghanistan contact Group has been established.
Efforts are being made to synchronize the activities of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) with the SCO structures in countering terrorism, organized crime, drug trafficking, as well as in supporting stability and security in the region as a whole. A memorandum of cooperation between the two international organizations was signed.
Inter-parliamentary cooperation is developing, and the institutionalization of this cooperation, in my opinion, may actually indicate the completion of the construction of this international organization. A plan has been approved for the formation of the regular mechanism of inter - parliamentary dialogue of the SCO member states - the Inter-Parliamentary Assembly.
Despite such a multi-format development of cooperation, the parties have reached an understanding that they need to place special emphasis on its economic component. In May 2002, the first meeting of ministers responsible for foreign economic and trade activities was held in Shanghai, and in October 2002, the first SCO Forum on Investment and Development in the Field of Energy was held in Beijing.
In 2003, the organization adopted the Program of Multilateral Trade and Economic Cooperation, which defines the main guidelines and stages of economic integration for the period up to 2020. The program provides for the creation of the most favorable conditions for trade and investment in order to ensure the gradual implementation of free movement of goods, capital, services and technologies in the SCO space. However, we are not talking about the free movement of labor yet, since the rest of the alliance members are not yet ready for a massive influx of labor from China, to put it mildly. In other words, the desire to create a free trade zone is actually declared. In 2004, an Action Plan for the implementation of this Program was signed, which includes more than 120 specific projects and areas of cooperation, as well as provides for mechanisms for their phased implementation.15 Since it was clear from the very beginning that it would not be possible to implement all the projects at once, a Commission of Senior Officials was established to select the most important pilot projects. In 2005, the mechanism for implementing the action plan for the implementation of the program was approved.
The program of multilateral trade and economic cooperation outlines the main tasks of the SCO in the field of economy. These include promoting trade and capital investment, developing transport links and energy, telecommunications and high technologies, as well as protecting the environment and solving the problem of drinking water.
Within the framework of the SCO, additional facilities have been created:
- Business Council - a non-governmental organization that unites business and financial circles of the organization's member states;
- Interbank association;
- The SCO Development Fund is a kind of joint investment bank, through which the organization's economic projects will be financed; it is assumed that through it, the capitals of some member countries will be able to invest in the development of the world economy.-
page 12
enter the financial markets of other SCO member states;
- The Forum is a multi-pronged public consultative and expert mechanism aimed at developing cooperation between research and political science centers of the organization's member countries 16.
A wide variety of international structures are involved in the development and implementation of specific SCO projects. For example, experts from the organization's member countries, together with the SCO Secretariat and the Asian Development Bank, are currently working on a draft agreement between the Governments of the SCO member States on creating more favorable conditions for international road transport. Work has begun on creating a single transport space of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization.
WHAT CONNECTS THE SIX STATES...
If we compare the SCO, for example, with the CIS, it should be noted that in this case there are no equally obvious reasons for unification. The interests of the Organization's Member States are often generally divergent. There are even contradictions and tensions between its members, in particular, between Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan. Nevertheless, as we mentioned above, Afghanistan, Belarus, India, Iran, Mongolia, and Pakistan are all attracted to unification.17
This position of states so different in their socio-political appearance is cemented by the unwillingness of their governments and peoples to accept the model of the new world order imposed by the current US administration. It is easier for these countries to negotiate among themselves than with Washington.
During their meetings, representatives of the SCO member states regularly speak out about the need to respect multiculturalism, respect and preserve the diversity of civilizations in the world, as well as the multi-variant development paths of different countries. This line distinguishes this association from Western and especially from American integration projects.18
Recent events in Central Asia clearly indicate that the region is still far from stable. Recent events in Uzbekistan and the "velvet" change of leadership in Kyrgyzstan do not add to hopes for a calm development of the Central Asian region. Fuel to the fire is added by the periodically uttered statements of representatives of Western countries about the alleged "lack of democracy" in the former republics of the USSR. That is why the SCO members consider the new association primarily as a tool for ensuring stability in the region.19
In the West, the presence of two countries - Russia and China-in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization is of particular concern. There are concerns that their membership and joint work in the SCO will eventually lead to a dangerous combination of the economic potentials of the two giants. This is unlikely to happen in the foreseeable future. But the active economic and military expansion of the United States and Europe in the Central Asian region does not meet the geopolitical interests of these two countries (as, indeed, the interests of other SCO members). Therefore, this association is aimed, among other things, at jointly repelling the massive (and in many directions) offensive of the West. In this regard, it should be emphasized that the basis for the unification of Russia and China within the SCO is primarily a political, not an economic union.
In support of this, many facts can be cited. Thus, at a meeting in Astana on July 6, 2005, the heads of the SCO countries adopted a declaration calling on the United States to close military bases deployed in Central Asia under the slogan of protecting the region from extremists.20
In the future, if the paths of the Russian Federation and the People's Republic of China do not diverge dramatically, the SCO has great chances to grow beyond the framework of a defensive alliance and declare itself as a new pole in a multipolar world. But without a strong, developed "economic component", the association will not be able to claim such a role.
...AND WHAT SEPARATES THEM
Despite the seemingly monolithic appearance of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, many experts rightly point out a number of obvious contradictions between its members that may affect the further development of the SCO. Thus, the Program of Multilateral Trade and Economic Cooperation adopted in 2003 declares the intention to create a free trade zone within the organization. However, Russia failed to do this even with its closest partners in the CIS - what can we say about creating such a zone within a much more complex and multi-vector association?.. In addition, it is not clear what the economic consequences of removing all barriers to trade with China will be for the rest of the SCO members.
The mechanism of participation of SCO member states in other integration initiatives is not very clear. It is known that Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Russia, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan are also members of the CIS and EurAsEC. In addition, Kazakhstan and Russia have long been working together to create a Single Economic Space and China, in turn, participates in the association of ASEAN+3. At the same time, all of the mentioned integration associations also involve the creation of free trade zones of various formats.
Problems may also arise due to the fact that the SCO duplicates many of the functions of the Dushanbe-based Collective Security Treaty Organization.-
page 13
The Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), which includes four of the six members of the association.
A serious problem is the lack of some "natural integrity" of the SCO. Participants in the Organization are too different in terms of socio-economic development: on the one hand, "rich" Russia and China, and on the other - "poor" Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. This separation was evident as soon as it came to the implementation of common economic projects. Despite the official equality of all SCO members and the principle of joint financing of projects approved by all, the "poor" members of the Organization, under various pretexts, invariably ask the Russian Federation and the PRC to increase the Russian and Chinese shares of costs.
The second line of division was formed historically: on the one hand - China, on the other-all the others. The Central Asian republics and Russia are ready to increase cooperation with the PRC, but at the same time they are concerned about its growing power.
The most serious obstacle may be the divergence of the political and economic interests of the Russian Federation and the PRC. As you know, China has set itself the goal of becoming a global political and economic leader in this century. And to do this, it needs new markets for goods, additional sources of energy resources. Both of them are close at hand.
China has long been waging a massive offensive on the Central Asian market. Thus, its trade turnover with the Central Asian countries is almost comparable to Russia's trade with these countries. It generously provides them with export credits 21. In the absence of a well-thought-out policy in relation to the countries of this region, the PRC is turning the local economy in its direction by allocating multibillion-dollar funds (in the form of soft loans, etc.) for the implementation of various investment projects, initiating large-scale joint projects in the field of infrastructure. 22
China's high economic growth rate requires a constant increase in energy consumption. China is interested in Central Asia as a reliable supplier of energy resources. And participation in the SCO gives it the opportunity to legitimately be present along with Russia in Central Asia, which was considered precisely the Russian sphere of influence. Even now, China is trying to draw these countries as much as possible into its economic orbit through impressive financial injections.
The benefits for everyone are obvious: a stable demand for raw hydrocarbons is being created, trade relations are expanding, infrastructure is developing, and investments are coming in. However, there is a bleak prospect for the region to become an appendage of the Chinese economy. Some Southeast Asian countries have already faced a similar problem. To a certain extent, this threat also exists for our country. Thus, China, with the help of the SCO, is pushing Russia in Central Asia. Within the organization, the struggle for leadership and spheres of influence has unfolded and continues.
Knowing that China is extremely interested in Russian energy resources, Russia, however, refused to build an oil pipeline from Angarsk to Daqing. Despite Beijing's insistence on this issue, the Russian side chose a different route for the pipeline-to the Pacific coast, entirely through the territory of our country. And the point here is not so much that Japan is ready to finance this option, but rather that it is unwilling to close the pipe to China. At the same time, the Russian Federation agrees to make a branch from this oil pipeline to China.
However, there are also positive examples when bilateral Russian-Chinese problems were successfully resolved precisely because of cooperation within the SCO. Thus, an intergovernmental agreement on the joint construction of a new bridge over the Argun River on the border of the Chita Region and the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region and an intergovernmental protocol on the establishment of a Russian-Chinese working group on migration issues were recently signed.
If you weigh all the pros and cons of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, the pros still outweigh it. The SCO performs its main function quite well: now it is not only a deterrent to American expansion in the region, but also an effective tool for regional economic integration and cooperation. This is currently the most important thing in ensuring peace and stability in this region.
1 Shanghai Cooperation Organization. Справка // "Новости NEWSru.com" - http://www.newsru.com/background/15jun2006/shosl.html
2 Ibid.
3 Ibid.
4 Declaration on the Establishment of the SCO of June 15, 2001 - http://president.kremlin.ru
5 Convention for the Suppression of Terrorism, Separatism and Extremism of 15 June 2001 - http://president.kremlin.ru
6 SCO Charter of June 7, 2002 - http://president.kremlin.ru
7 Agreement between the SCO Member States on the Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure of June 7, 2002 - http://president.kremlin.ru
8 Declaration of the Heads of SCO Member States of 29 May 2003 - http://president.kremlin.ru
9 Shanghai Cooperation Organization // Encyclopedia of Circumnavigation of the World - http://www.krugosvet.ru/articles/107/1010706/
10 The SCO Charter...
11 Declaration of the Heads of SCO member States...
Milovzorov A. 12 Another zone is being built in Asia. Russia participates (October 1, 2003) - http://www.utro.ru/articles/2003/10/01/ 236648. shtml
13 Declaration of the Fifth Anniversary of the SCO of June 16, 2006 - http://www.mid.ru
14 See, for example: Grinev P. Russia and Iran will subjugate half the planet (May 31, 2006) - http://www.utro.ru/articles/2006/05/31/ 552630. shtml
15 Shanghai Cooperation Organization (July 5-6, 2005) - http://president.kremlin.ru
16 See, for example: Milovzorov A. Druzhba v Ameriki - delo tonkoe (October 27, 2005) - http://www.utro.ru/articles/2005/10/27/489783.shtml
Krushinskaya K. 17 Americans are being expelled from Central Asia (July 6, 2005) - http://www.utro.ru/articles/2005/07/06/455744.shtml
18 Declaration of the fifth Anniversary of the SCO...
Antonov S. 19 The Warsaw Pact-2 / / Weekly Magazine, Moscow, 2003, No. 17.
Milovzorov A. 20 The gravedigger of the West grows and grows stronger (June 19, 2006) - http://www.utro.ru/articles/2006/06/19/557785.shtml
21 Chinese expansion to Central Asia: a game of advance or offensive? Expert Opinion (dated August 5, 2007) - http://www.regnum.ru/news/866290.html
22 See, for example: Ionova E. The Eastern vector in the Foreign economic policy of Central Asian countries // Russia and the Muslim World, 2005, No. 9.
Новые публикации: |
Популярные у читателей: |
Новинки из других стран: |
![]() |
Контакты редакции |
О проекте · Новости · Реклама |
|
Либмонстр Россия ® Все права защищены.
2014-2026, LIBMONSTER.RU - составная часть международной библиотечной сети Либмонстр (открыть карту) Сохраняя наследие России |
Россия
Беларусь
Украина
Казахстан
Молдова
Таджикистан
Эстония
Россия-2
Беларусь-2
США-Великобритания
Швеция
Сербия