(Chronological and technological aspects of the "Torgazhak" tradition in the Sayano-Altai Highlands)
Yu. F. Kiryushin 1, P. V. Volkov 2, K. Y. Kiryushin 1
1 Altai State University
61 Lenin Ave., Barnaul, 656049, Russia
E-mail: rector@asu.ru
2 Institute of Archeology and Ethnography SB RAS
17 Akademika Lavrentieva Ave., Novosibirsk, 630090, Russia
E-mail: wolf@archaeology.nsc.ru
Introduction
A representative collection of engraved pebbles obtained during excavations at the settlement of Torgazhak (XI-IX centuries BC) on the middle Yenisei [Savinov. 1996, p. 46; 2003, p. 50], became a kind of standard with which all such finds are compared. Ornamental pebbles and tiles found on the territory of the Sayan-Altai Highlands are not comparable in quantity to this collection (Savinov, 2003, p. 52). In this paper, we are not going to comprehensively consider the problem of the emergence of the "Torgazhak" tradition, but will focus only on the technological and chronological aspects.
History of studying the Tytkesken-2 settlement
The monument is located in the middle reaches of the Katun River on the second left-bank terrace above the floodplain, on the right bank of the Tytkesken Stream, in its pre-estuary part. The total area of the settlement is approx. 6 thousand m2. It was discovered by M. T. Abdulganeev in 1983 [1985, p. 189]. In 1984-1986, A. L. Kungurov and N. Yu. Kungurova excavated about 70 m2 of the settlement area in small excavations [1986], and from 1988 to 1994, under the direction of Yu.F. Kiryushin, more than 1066 m2 were excavated in stationary excavations [Kiryushin Yu. F., Kiryushin K. Yu., 1993, p. 25]. The entire area under study is exposed to alluvium, which is coarse river sand (fractions from 0.05 to 10 mm) with a pebble-block material of good roundness. The total thickness of the exposed sediments ranges from 0.45 to 2.6 m (Baryshnikov and Kiryushin, 1990, pp. 26-27).
The monument has a complex stratigraphy. In the course of work at the Tytkesken-2 settlement, one feature was noted: the greatest thickness of Aeolian sands, reaching 1.6 m, is observed in the north-eastern part of the excavation closer to the Katun riverbed; here they form an Aeolian ridge (Baryshnikov and Maloletko, 1997, Fig. 61). Layers containing archaeological finds stand out in sections with a darker color due to their greater humus content. The sterile layers of Aeolian sand are lighter, and their thickness between the cultural horizons in this part of the excavation reaches 0.4 m. Closer to the mountain slope, the thickness of Aeolian sand is higher.
This work was supported by RGNF project N05 - 01 - 01390a.
page 84
the origin decreases, gradually coming to naught (Baryshnikov and Kiryushin, 1990, Fig. 2).
Planigraphic and stratigraphic conditions for the occurrence of shale tiles with an anthropomorphic image
In 1988, a long-term semi-earth dwelling No. 1 was excavated [Kiryushin Yu. F., Kiryushin K. Yu., 1993, p. 25; Kiryushin, 2004, p. 11]. Its filling differed in color due to its greater humus content from the layer of low-humus sandy loam into which it was embedded. This layer contained finds dating back to the advanced Neolithic period. On the border between the filling of the dwelling and low-humus sandy loam, a material called complex 5A was collected. It was formed as a result of the mechanical mixing of artifacts from the Advanced Neolithic era, which lay in a layer of low-humus sandy loam, and Bolynemyss from dwelling No. 1, which belong to the Eneolithic [Ibid.]. Complex 5A contains slate tiles with a cut pattern (Fig. 1).
Description of the find
The material used for manufacturing the product is hydro - mica shale, strongly sandy, transitional from clay shales to silicite (the definitions were made by N. A. Kulik, a senior researcher at the Institute of Electric Power Engineering of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Candidate of Geological and Mineral Sciences).
The tile is flat, sub-triangular in shape, 3.5 mm thick, 49 mm long, 28.5 mm wide. The ornament is engraved on one side. It is sanded. It should be particularly noted that this side of the tile is covered with a thin layer of carbonate plaque (traces of lifting carbonates by ground water), and it is also located inside the drawn lines that create the ornament.
Visual fields (top and bottom) were visually displayed on the tile. At the top, in its narrow part, you can see a ribbon in the shape of a corner, decorated with rhombuses, at the bottom, in the wide part, there is an arc-shaped strip, also filled with rhombuses.
Results of the trasological examination of tiles
On the ornamented tile surface, in some cases, the lines formed during the grinding process and drawn during the application of the ornament are visually indistinguishable. As a result of trace analysis, it was found that the first ones have a smoothed bottom and sides in the profile section (Fig. 2, 2), and the second ones, cut by a sharp, presumably metal object, have a sharply narrowing bottom and an angular interface between the gutter wall and the stone surface (Fig. 2, 3). A clear differentiation according to the above signs allows you to easily distinguish linear traces of grinding and, excluding them, present the scheme of an ornamental composition (Fig. 2, 1).
The lower image field consists of two parts (upper and lower), separated by several lines directed from the side edges to the central axis of the tile. It is all covered with a grid of rhombuses; the lower part is additionally worked out with short vertical strokes ("fringe"). From left to right and from bottom to top runs a diagonal strip, the so-called baldric, formed by 15-20 lines. The tracological study allowed us to determine the sequence of applying the lower field ornament. First, a diamond mesh and a "sling" were made, after that
Fig. 1. Slate tile with an anthropomorphic image from the Tytkesken-2 settlement.
page 85
2. Diagram of the ornamental composition of tiles (1) and profile section of linear grinding traces (2) and cut lines (3). a - a line formed by three or four carver passes; b-lines formed by two carver passes.
the upper and lower lines delineating the ornamental field are drawn, last of all the "fringe" is made. The sequence of drawing diagonal lines forming the "sling" could not be determined.
In the upper part of the tile, slightly above the ribbon decorated with rhombuses, four lines are cut at the bend, which converge at an acute angle with each other. In our opinion, the ancient master depicted the mouth of a person with these lines. Traceological examination of the tile revealed details that were not visible during visual inspection. In the upper narrow part of the tile, three short lines (one on the left and two on the right) are identified, oriented from its edges with an inclination to the vertical axis (Fig. 2, 1). In our opinion, they represent the eyes of a person.
Almost all lines are made by a single carver's passage through the processed material, only one - by three or four (Fig. 2, 1, a) and two-by two (Fig. 2, 1, b). Along the entire perimeter, the traces of the carver slightly extend to the end plane of the tile, which indicates the integrity of the artifact (its preservation in an unfragmented state).
Tile dating
When dating this artifact, the results of trace analysis play a decisive role. With a high degree of probability, it can be argued that the ornament on the tile was cut with a metal knife. This circumstance is consistent with the data of field observations and has already been noted by the authors of the article [Kiryushin Yu. F., Kiryushin K. Yu., 1993, p. 25; Kiryushin, 2004, p. 11]. As mentioned above, complex 5A is mixed, most of it belongs to the developed Neolithic, but there are artifacts of a later time (Eneolithic). Unfortunately, we do not yet have radiocarbon dates for dwelling No. 1 of the third cultural horizon. There are two dates for Final Neolithic materials (see the table).
Dwelling No. 1 of the third horizon, in our opinion, dates back to the end of the IV-beginning of the III millennium BC. The collections of stone tools from this dwelling show changes in the technique of splitting stone compared to earlier Neolithic complexes. When removing large plates, percussion techniques were used using an intermediary made of horn or bone [Kiryushin, 2004, p. 13]. In comparison with the Neolithic layers, the number of bifaces, arrowheads, and large plates increases, and the proportion of points and incisors in the tool kit decreases [Ibid., p. 20]. A metal awl found in the filling of dwelling No. 1 allowed us to assign the Bolshemyss complexes to the Eneolithic [Kiryushin Yu. F., Kiryushin K. Yu., 1993, p. 25; Kiryushin, 2004, p. 16]. The assumption made as a result of the tracological study of the artifact that a metal knife was used as a tool for applying ornaments is consistent with earlier conclusions about the Eneolithic age of the Bolypemyss materials of the Tytkesken-2 settlement.
Results of dating animal bones from the Horizon 4 dwelling filling
Code
Half-life 14 C = 5570 years
Age, years BC
Half-life 14 C = 5730 years
Age, years BC
SOAN-5148
5360 ± 90
3410 ±90
5520 ± 90
3570 ± 90
GIN-8456
5430 ±140
3480 ±140
5590 ±140
3640 ±140
page 86
Analogues among shingles and tiles of the "Torgazhak" type and problems of their dating
The earliest analogs of the considered find on the territory of Altai are tiles with scratched ornaments from the settlement of Kornachak-2 on Chumysh (Prisalairya district). A radiocarbon date of 7340 ± 175 BP (5390 BC) was obtained from coal from the hearth of this settlement (Kungurov, 1997, p. 102). Tiles from Kornachak-2, in our opinion, do not belong to the Torgazhak tradition proper. D. G. Savinov considers them "imaginary analogs" [2003, p. 52], and we agree with him. At the same time, these finds testify to the tradition of decorating tiles already in the Neolithic period.
Ornamental pebbles are now known on the middle Katun River (Ust-Kuyum settlement). Kungurova dates them to the fourth millennium BC [2003, p.81, 84] and refers them, like D. G. Savinov, to the Torgazhak tradition [Ibid., p. 83; Savinov, 2003, p. 52]. Among them, there are pebbles with geometric ornaments similar to the Torgazhak products (Savinov, 2003, Fig. 10); there are specimens with a belt of triangles facing down, revealing analogies among the pebbles of the first group (anthropomorphic images) from the settlement of Torgazhak. In our opinion, the attribution of pebbles from Ust-Kuyum to the Torgazhak tradition is somewhat conditional, since the similarities are very insignificant and can only be seen at the level of individual elements of the composition. In our opinion, these products reflect a certain stage in the development of the tradition of engraving pebbles from earlier "imaginary analogues" to the actual Torgazhak ones.
Tiles from Tytkeskenya-2 undoubtedly belong to the Torgazhak tradition itself. Here we can observe not just the similarity of individual elements of the composition, but almost identical picture. The closest analogs of the product under consideration are found among the pebbles of the first group from the settlement of Torgazhak (anthropomorphic images) [Savinov, 1996, Tables XXIII, 3; XXIV, 5, 6; XXV, 7, 8]. The tile from Tytkesken has no "cap", but there is a "face", highlighted by a ribbon of diamonds, on which the eyes and mouth are marked. On the lower ornamental field, divided into two horizontal parts, the "fringe" is visible and the "baldric" is clearly visible. Tiles from the settlement of Tytkesken-2 have a lot in common with the pebbles of Torgazhak, starting with the form and ending with individual elements of the composition. The only differences are in the nature of the blank (tiles, not pebbles).
Ornamental tiles were found on the settlement of Toora-Dash in Tuva. A broken plate of petrified wood with scratched ornaments was found in the Neolithic layer (Semenov, 1992, p. 103, Fig. 20, 13); two tiles with a geometric pattern were found in the sixth and seventh horizons belonging to the Okunev culture (Ibid., p. 102, fig. 19, 3, 4). A. Semenov also writes about similar finds from the ninth and tenth layers of the Toora-Dash settlement [2000, p. 138]. He dates the tenth one to the Scythian period [Ibid., p. 139]. Ornamental pebbles are found in the settlements of Khadynnykh-1 (Okunevskaya culture) and Etekshil (Bronze Age) in Tuva (Semenov, 1992, p. 102, Fig. 19, 1, 2, 5, 7, 8].
D. G. Savinov questioned the dating of finds from the settlements of Ust-Kuyum, Toora-Dash, and Etekshil, which was proposed by the authors of the excavations [2003, p. 51]. We do not undertake to judge the age of tiles and pebbles from the last two monuments, but we agree with D. G. Savinov about the Ust-Kuyum collection that it can be dated to a later time. At this stage of research, the Neolithic age of the tiles from the Kornachak-2 settlement and the Eneolithic age of the tiles from Tytkeskenya-2 are beyond doubt. Unfortunately, there is still no data on the traceological analysis of products from the settlements of Ust-Kuyum and Kornachak-2. It is possible that a similar study will be conducted in the future, which will allow us to clarify the dating of these collections.
Key findings
Ornamental tiles from the Tytkesken-2 settlement, in our opinion, belong to the Eneolithic era and date back to the end of the IV-beginning of the III millennium BC. As D. G. Savinov rightly noted, ornamental pebbles similar to Torgazhak ones from the territory of the Sayan-Altai Highlands are not comparable in quantity to those found at the Torgazhak settlement (Savinov, 2003, p. 52]. However, the number of such finds continues to increase. At the present stage of studying the problem, we can state that the production of ornamental pebbles and tiles ("imaginary analogues") on the territory of the Sayano-Altai Highlands originated in the Neolithic era, and not in the final Bronze Age. In the Eneolithic materials of the Tytkesken-2 settlement, we find a sample similar to the Torgazhak pebbles. In our opinion, this may indicate the similarity of cultural traditions and ideological (religious) beliefs of the population of the Sayan-Altai Highlands in the Eneolithic and Late Bronze Age.
page 87
List of literature
Abdulganeev M. T. Raboty v gornom i lesostepnom Altae [Works in the mountain and forest-steppe Altai]. AO 1983, Moscow, 1985, pp. 189-190.
Baryshnikov G. Ya., Kiryushin Yu. F. Geologicheskie i geomorphologicheskie usloviya formirovaniya arkheologicheskogo pamyatela Tytkesken v srednego potok Katun [Geological and geomorphological conditions for the formation of the archaeological monument Tytkesken in the middle reaches of the Katun River].
Baryshnikov G. Ya., Maloletko A.M. Archaeological sites of Altai through the eyes of geologists. - Tomsk: Publishing House of the Tomsk State University, 1997. - Part 1. - 160 p.
Kiryushin K. Y. Kul'turno-khronologicheskie kompleksy poseleniya Tytkesken-2: Avtoref. dis. ... kand. ist. nauk [Cultural and chronological complexes of the Tytkesken-2 settlement]. Novosibirsk, 2004, 23 p. (in Russian)
Kiryushin Yu. F., Kiryushin K. Yu. Bolynemyssky complex of the settlement Tytkesken-2 / / Kul'tura drevnykh narodov Yuzhnoy Sibiri [Culture of ancient peoples of Southern Siberia]. Barnaul: Alt State University Publ., 1993, pp. 25-30.
Kungurov A. L. Neolithic of the Upper Prichumysh Region // Preservation and study of the cultural heritage of the Altai Territory: Materials of scientific research. Barnaul: Alt. State University Press, 1997, issue 8, pp. 98-104.
Kungurov A. L., Kungurova N. Yu. Raboty Biiskogo otryada [Works of the Biysk detachment], AO 1984, Moscow: Nauka Publ., 1986, pp. 287-288.
Kungurova N. Yu. Graphic images on the pebbles of Ust-Kuyum / / Steppes of Eurasia in antiquity and the Middle Ages. - St. Petersburg: State Publishing House. Hermitage, 2003, Book 2, pp. 81-84.
Savinov D. G. Ancient settlements of Khakassia. St. Petersburg: Peterburgskoe vostokovedenie Publ., 1996, 112 p. (in Russian)
Savinov D. G. Torgazhak pebbles (main aspects of studying, interpretation) / / Archeology, Ethnography and Anthropology of Eurasia. - 2003. - N 2 (14). - p. 48-71.
Semenov V. A. Neolithic and Bronze Age of Tuva. - St. Petersburg: LNIAO Publishing House, 1992. - 152 p.
Semenov V. A. Etapy sostaveniya kul'tury rannykh kochevnikov Tuva [Stages of adding up the culture of early nomads of Tuva]. The ritual. Culture. St. Petersburg: Mir Knigi Foundation, 2000, pp. 134-155.
The article was submitted to the Editorial Board on 12.05.05.
page 88
Новые публикации: |
Популярные у читателей: |
Новинки из других стран: |
![]() |
Контакты редакции |
О проекте · Новости · Реклама |
|
Либмонстр Россия ® Все права защищены.
2014-2026, LIBMONSTER.RU - составная часть международной библиотечной сети Либмонстр (открыть карту) Сохраняя наследие России |
Россия
Беларусь
Украина
Казахстан
Молдова
Таджикистан
Эстония
Россия-2
Беларусь-2
США-Великобритания
Швеция
Сербия